Showing posts with label Department of Ecological Fallacies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Department of Ecological Fallacies. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

"Moscow City still waiting for EPA decision"

If Moscow, which is upstream from Pullman, is not required to implement the Phase II stormwater regulations when Pullman has already been forced to do so, it will prove the whole process is just a sham and a farce.

From yesterday's Moscow-Pullman Daily News:
The city of Moscow should hear from the Environmental Protection Agency regarding its Stormwater Phase II status in the next four to six weeks, EPA officials say.

The City Council sent the EPA a letter in August asking not to be subject to Phase II stormwater regulations. It anticipated receiving a reply in the fall.

"They (the EPA) just haven't made their decision yet," Moscow Public Works Director Les MacDonald said.

If Moscow is listed as a regulated small municipal separate storm system under Phase II, it will be required to develop a comprehensive stormwater management program and obtain a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit, according to a letter sent by an EPA Region 10 official in June.

The regulations are designed to manage the quality and quantity of runoff from development and to control stormwater discharge. The requirements are intended to reduce downstream pollution and contamination.

The council members who voted to send the August letter said Moscow should be self-guided as it improves stormwater management.

EPA spokesman Jeff Philip said the EPA has delayed its decision because it still is looking at the data.

"It's taking a while to go through the data and really make a solid determination on whether (Moscow) should be included or not," Philip said.

Philip said there is no firm deadline for the decision, "but we want to get it done as soon as possible so they're not waiting and we're not waiting."


Tuesday, February 5, 2008

"Hawkins to tap into Moscow's water; City to sell services to development company looking to build retail center in Pullman-Moscow corridor"

That's a headline I never thought I would post here!! Hawkins and Colton get their water and the Department of Ecology can no longer hold up our development! The Border War is over and Moscow and Whitman County can start cooperating again on issues that matter.

From today's Moscow-Pullman Daily News:
The city of Moscow has changed its stance on a proposed development in Whitman County.

The City Council voted 5-1 Monday to sell water to Hawkins Companies for use at its proposed 700,000-square-foot retail development, which would be situated just across the state line in the Pullman-Moscow corridor.

The city also agreed to drop its appeal of a water rights transfer by Hawkins.

A settlement agreement between the entities was developed during two days of mediation between Moscow, Hawkins, the Washington State Department of Ecology and the city of Colton last week in Spokane.

The council had to vote on the settlement without disclosing its content to the public because of a confidentiality requirement of the mediation.

Councilmen Walter Steed and Wayne Krauss, Mayor Nancy Chaney and Public Works Director Les MacDonald attended the mediation. The full council discussed the settlement in a private session before Monday night's meeting.

Tom Lamar was the only council member to vote against the agreement.

The agreement states that, pending permitting by the Idaho Department of Water Resources, Moscow will provide up to 45 acre-feet of drinkable water per year and up to 20 acre-feet of irrigation water per year, unless Hawkins uses reclaimed water for irrigation. The city also will provide water for fire protection for the development.

The city also is offering Hawkins sewer treatment services. Hawkins has 90 days to decide whether to accept the services and must build a sewage treatment facility on its property if it does not accept the deal with Moscow. Hawkins has estimated it will cost $2 million to build a sewage treatment plant at the site.

If Moscow develops a reclaimed water supply for irrigation, Hawkins can negotiate a deal to use it. Steed said the 20 acre-feet designated for irrigation will be removed from the deal if Hawkins uses reclaimed water, whether from Moscow or its own treatment plant.

The city will charge Hawkins rates that are "fair and reasonable and consistent with rates and charges set for similarly situated customers of the city," the agreement states.

According to the agreement, Hawkins is responsible for the capital costs of extending water utilities from the city to the development. Whitman County has agreed to sell bonds to pay for public infrastructure at the site.

Moscow will withdraw the appeals of three Hawkins water rights that it filed with the Washington State Pollution Control Hearings Board.

Hawkins will withdraw its appeal of one water right, an annual 63-acre-feet draw from the Wanapum aquifer, that was rejected by the board.

Colton will get 100 acre-feet of annual water rights it negotiated in a deal with Hawkins.

Hawkins will have the right to exercise two of its water rights until city water service begins, at which time Hawkins will relinquish its rights and retire them permanently.

Krauss said he went into the mediation knowing the final decision would make some people unhappy, but it had to be reached.

"This a real case of being caught between a rock and hard spot when you do something like this and you make a decision," he said.

Steed said the agreement provides revenue for Moscow and causes no net increase in withdrawals from the Grand Ronde aquifer.

He said Palouse Basin Aquifer Committee officials believe the agreement will create a net decrease in water usage compared to the usage that could happen if Hawkins had all its water rights approved and Moscow lost its appeal.

"We believe there are benefits to the city of Moscow and its citizens in the agreement," Steed said.

Lamar said he voted against the proposal because he doesn't see a clear benefit for Moscow and its residents. [Waaahhhh. Get used to being the single "No" vote Lamar - tf]

"Personally, I'm concerned with the details and the precedent that may be set with decisions if we are to accept this," he said.

He said he doesn't think the city should sell water rights across the state line because Moscow has no ability to annex or tax the development. The development also could have negative ramifications for Moscow businesses.

"Once we decide to sell water to Hawkins, it's no longer just the water issue, it's the city of Moscow helping to make that development happen," he said.

Chaney said she would have voted against the agreement if given the chance. [Of course she would have. Luckily Mayor Moonbat has become Mayor Irrelevant - tf]

She said the agreement saves Hawkins money, which will expedite additional development in the corridor that will draw even more water from a declining aquifer.

"I'm not comfortable that we have all the information in hand yet," she said.

Several Moscow residents who spoke before the vote on the agreement said they were upset with the confidentiality.

"The people here are concerned (about water issues). They are interested," Moscow resident David Pierce said. "The fact that you are willing, it appears, to approve a mitigation and a compromise on this thing without involving the people of the area I think is a great travesty to the people of this area."

Several people also were concerned that the council is jeopardizing the future of Moscow's water resources by agreeing to extend services to Hawkins.

"I also am concerned that the city is willing to mortgage our children's future and put their water rights at risk and destroying possibly two existing wells and our downtown in order to put money in other people's pockets," Moscow resident Betsy Dickow said.

Moscow resident David Hall said selling water to Hawkins causes Moscow to lose its credibility as a city concerned about water.

"Moscow needs to do a full water budget before it can even consider providing water to outside entities," Hall said.

Many council members said they were uncomfortable about not being able to discuss the agreement before the vote.

Steed said confidentiality "was placed upon us. We didn't ask for it. We didn't particularly want to do it that way."

Lamar said Moscow residents will have the chance to share their opinions about the agreement during the Idaho Department of Water Resources permitting process, which will be conducted by the state.

Lambert said Moscow's representatives at the mediation could have just walked away, but it would have left the city with no control over how Hawkins uses its water rights.

"This issue is not a cut-and-dried issue where we've got the right to stop what they're doing over there, and everybody in this town needs to understand that," Lambert said. "At least we've got the right to determine how much water we can give them."

Whitman County Commissioner Jerry Finch said Moscow's decision takes "a big impediment off the process."

"I think it is a win-win for both the county and the city of Moscow," Finch said. "We've come a long way. Six months ago I would have never thought they would sell Hawkins water."

Sunday, January 27, 2008

Mixed Econuts: Unfunded Mandates

Get ready to reach into your wallets to protect the non-existent Palouse River salmon. Dino Rossi needs to clean house at the Department of Ecology after he is elected. From last Wednesday's Moscow-Pullman Daily News:
Pullman accepts state money for stormwater work

Pullman City Councilman Keith Bloom doesn't mind being a rebel.

Bloom cast the lone opposing vote Tuesday as the council voted to accept $50,000 in state funding to help the city institute elements of statewide municipal stormwater permits issued by the Washington State Department of Ecology in February 2007.

The permits have been viewed locally as a heavy-handed way to manage runoff from development and control stormwater discharges into sewer systems, with a goal of reducing pollution and contamination of downstream waters. Permits also require municipalities to manage construction stormwater, detect and eliminate illegal discharges, create good housekeeping practices for existing systems and educate the public.

The council and city staff have protested the permits because of the city's unique topography and because Pullman already has many protective measures in place.

The cost to implement the five-year permit is expected to exceed $4 million. The city was given a $75,000 grant from the state in 2007, and the council has discussed creating a stormwater utility district to help pay for the permit costs.

The city is appealing the permits along with several other members of the Washington Association of Cities.

Bloom said his opposing vote was meant to be symbolic.

"A vote 'yes' means we begin the process to raise taxes. It's blood money," he said. "It's giving us $50,000 so we can turn around and pay them $500,000 (in fees). ... I'm not going to march lock step with the DOE on this."

Public Works Director Mark Workman said the money likely will be spent to organize a fee schedule for the proposed utility district. Representatives from the city's stormwater consultant, Otak, Inc., soon will begin to evaluate the impervious surfaces on about 200 residential properties throughout Pullman. The numbers will be averaged and used to generate an Equivalent Residential Unit - a fee structure for the stormwater utility customers. Fees for industrial and commercial businesses will be tabulated individually.

The council also voted in favor of upping the city's contribution to appeal the permit to $33,333.33.

Pullman joined forces with 32 other Washington cities last year to appeal the permit, arguing it is too restrictive and goes beyond what is required by the Clean Water Act and the Ecology Construction Stormwater Permit. The city originally pledged to chip in $8,333.33 for the appeal.

Workman said the increased amount is needed for the cities to battle a cross-appeal filed by the Puget Sound Alliance, which claims the stormwater permits are not restrictive enough.

Saturday, January 26, 2008

"Wrangling over water rights will move to Spokane; Mediation set in dispute over Moscow-Pullman corridor work"

Another great article from David Johnson in last Thursday's Lewiston Tribune. Johnson uncovers the Imperial Mayoralty of Queen Nancy:
MOSCOW - The politics of water will move from the Palouse to Spokane Tuesday as officials meet in a closed-door mediation session to discuss the proposed Hawkins Companies shopping center.

Hawkins, a Boise-based development company, secured water rights transfers for its 700,000-square-foot mall in the Moscow-Pullman corridor. But Moscow Mayor Nancy Chaney appealed the transfers, igniting criticism the city is unjustifiably wielding legal clout across state lines.

Chaney said the appeals, which were filed with city council consent, stem from a genuine concern for the region's groundwater resources. Critics contend the mayor is more interested in stopping retail development in the corridor and elsewhere.

That view was voiced Tuesday night by developer Art Schultheis of Colton, who told Chaney and city council members that Moscow's appeals have effectively stopped housing construction in his Whitman County town. The city of Colton and Hawkins were about to exchange water rights when the appeals stopped the process.

"I'm here tonight to ask your city council of Moscow to rescind your appeal of the water rights transfer," Schultheis said.

Others, including Hawkins representatives and the Whitman County commissioners, have blasted the Moscow appeals as little more than a legal lever geared toward halting development.

Moscow City Attorney Randy Fife said Wednesday the mediation session may help iron out differences. He also confirmed the new city council could, by majority vote, simply rescind the appeals.

"As far as I'm concerned, the city of Moscow should have no standing in the state of Washington," Schultheis said.

But when it comes to water rights and resources, Fife said, laws in Washington and Idaho recognize that groundwater flows beneath borders.

"One of the problems is that it was initiated in executive session and nobody will talk about it," Schultheis said of the Moscow appeals. Fife said Chaney, under the city's strong-mayor type of government, has authority to file such appeals after seeking general agreement from council members during an executive session.

The new council, with five professed pro-development members, appears willing to continue closed door talks at least through next week's mediation session.

Overall regional water supply issues aside, Fife said Moscow is concerned specifically that the Hawkins development could have an adverse effect on a city well located near the development site.

If water supply is the real fear, critics have said, Moscow should have a moratorium on new housing developments and challenge other construction projects, such as the new Washington State University golf course, which will use much more water than the proposed Hawkins shopping mall.

Water experts have said Moscow and Pullman share underground aquifers and water levels have been dropping by about 1.5 feet annually.

Moscow hired water rights attorney Peter Scott, of Helena, Mont., as lead counsel in the appeal process. Fife estimated Scott's services are costing the city about $200 an hour. In addition to Moscow officials, representatives from Whitman County, the city of Colton, Hawkins Companies, and others are expected to attend the mediation session, Fife said, adding mediation provides a vehicle for much needed dialogue.

"Everybody has been talking about talking," Fife said. "Now Hawkins gets to sit down and tell the city what it needs and wants.".

Hawkins spokesman Jeff De Voe has said his company needs water and wants Moscow to share its municipal supply or stop interfering with attempts to secure water rights for their own wells. De Voe declined additional comment because of the pending mediation.

Mediator Cassandra Noble, of the Washington Pollution Control Hearings Board, is scheduled to oversee the Tuesday session. Fife said mediation might last longer than one day and an accord won't necessarily be struck.

In addition to Chaney and himself, Fife said Councilor Wayne Krauss and Public Works Director Les McDonald are expected to attend the mediation session.

"Hawkins, Moscow will talk water"

From last Wednesday's Moscow-Pullman Daily News:
Developer, city will try to resolve differences next week in Spokane; Whitman County residents voice concerns about plan to pay for infrastructure

Hawkins Companies representatives said Tuesday they plan to meet with officials from the city of Moscow in an attempt to resolve water-rights issues surrounding the company's plans to build a shopping center just west of the Washington-Idaho state line.

Hawkins spokesman Jeff DeVoe said Moscow is seeking mediation with the company in an effort to reach an agreement over four separate water rights that are being appealed with the Washington State Pollution Control Hearings Board.

"We are willing to listen and come in with an open mind," DeVoe said after a public meeting in Colfax to discuss the proposed sale of $10.5 million in bonds to build infrastructure at the development site. "We are a shopping center developer and that's our goal. We are willing to do whatever makes sense."

Moscow City Attorney Randy Fife said the meeting is scheduled for Tuesday in Spokane.

Fife said a mediator will direct the meeting, ask questions, and offer scenarios and solutions until a resolution is reached. The Moscow City Council would have to approve the resolution before it could become official.

If a compromise or deal isn't reached, a hearing with the PCHB is scheduled to take place June 2-6 in Spokane.

During Tuesday's meeting with county commissioners, several Whitman County residents voiced their concerns over the proposed development and the county entering into a public-private partnership with Hawkins to sell bonds that would pay for public infrastructure necessary for the development. County commissioners plan to eventually pay back the bonds through property and sales taxes generated by the development.

Carolyn Kiesz said it took a lot of guts for the county commissioners to even float the idea of a bond meant to help a private corporation.

"Some of us in this county really don't want to let you get away with that," she told commissioners.

Kiesz said this is not the time for the county to potentially burden its taxpayers. The nation is facing the possibility of a recession and the development would only provide another outlet for foreign products, which means money going out of state and out of the country.

"I just don't think you should be asking for $10 million with no assurances of a return," Kiesz said.

She also said a retail shopping center would not help Whitman County reduce its high poverty rate, which is tops in the state of Washington according to recent statistics from the 2005 U.S. Census. The development would likely provide low-paying jobs and jobs to Moscow residents, and not to people in towns like Malden and Tekoa who really need jobs.

"I think you should be embarrassed" by those poverty-rate numbers, she said. "Bringing retail business is not going to fix that; bringing in manufacturing will help."

Duane Brelsford, president of Corporate Pointe Developers, said he has nothing but praise for Hawkins, but he is skeptical about providing more than $10 million for public infrastructure for the development unless the county is prepared to do the same for other developers. The cost of that would likely approach $100 million.

"I think we are setting a very dangerous precedent by providing infrastructure for this development," Brelsford said. "If we choose to go that direction I think we are going to need a lot more than $10 million because there are a lot more projects that are going in the corridor ... "

Commissioner Michael Largent said he welcomes opinions from those in favor of the bonds and those against the idea.

He also said he does not have all the answers yet, but he told people the commissioners are looking out for the public's interest.

"When we asked the public to give us their comments and start deliberating it didn't mean we had all the answers," Largent said. "Our responsibility is to the taxpayers of Whitman County and not Hawkins."

Commissioner Greg Partch stressed Whitman County would only move forward with the bonds if the deal was right for the county.

"This is not a done deal," Partch said. "We are not married to it. We are married to development on the corridor."

DeVoe added that Hawkins would not go forward with the development unless it was certain several issues - outside the control of Whitman County - could be resolved.

"Without water there is no bond," DeVoe said. "Without a tenant there is no bond and no infrastructure. We are not going to ask for a public-private partnership until those things are secured."

Commissioner Jerry Finch told meeting attendees the Hawkins development would lead to positive growth in the corridor, rather than "a hodgepodge of something we are all embarrassed with."

"I think if we put this shopping center in we will set the tenor for the whole corridor," Finch said. "If we don't, I am convinced there will be a series of steel buildings and parking lots. Whitman County and its citizens will be no better off than they are now."

Largent said the commissioners still hope to make a decision by the end of the month, but that it may be delayed if they aren't satisfied with all the information available.

Thursday, January 10, 2008

"Shopping center: Hawkins asks county to issue revenue bonds for $10+ million"

From today's Whitman County Gazette:
Hawkins Companies representatives from Boise Monday asked Whitman county commissioners to float revenue bonds of more than $10 million to help fund infrastructure at their company’s proposed shopping center in the Moscow-Pullman corridor on the Washington side of the state line.

County Commissioners will take public comment on the idea at their next two regular meetings, Jan. 14 and 22, and anticipate a decision by the end of the month.

“The county needs to get comfortable that they want to do this, and if they do we need to get moving forward with this,” Hawkins spokesman Jeff DeVoe said. “It’s our intention to get this shopping center built as soon as possible.”

DeVoe asked for the bond to fund an estimated $9.7 million to build roads, sidewalks, lighting and a water and sewer system at the site. DeVoe said Hawkins hopes to begin construction as early as the beginning of summer.

“It is our project, but understand that that infrastructure is the county’s, it belongs to the public,” said DeVoe.

That concerned some citizens in the audience, specifically Colton resident Art Schultheis, who asked how the extra cost of the infrastructure maintenance would be funded.

DeVoe replied water and sewer charges would pay for that upkeep. DeVoe said upkeep of roads would be “a part of what we pay our real property taxes to do.”

The bond plan was developed over the past six months in private meetings between DeVoe and Commissioner Jerry Finch.

The state’s open public meetings act requires the public to be notified when policy is discussed among more than one county commissioner, but allows for individual meetings.

“Much of the information here I have seen, but we felt it was now time to share this with the public,” said Finch.

Finch said DeVoe approached him about the bond as the company saw its resources used up by a lengthy pursuit of water for the development.

The development is currently awaiting a hearing on four water rights transfers from the state Pollution Control Hearings Board (PCHB).

“He told me, ‘we’re so pregnant with money into this project, we can’t afford to walk away’,” Finch told the Gazette Tuesday.

In addition to the mounting costs of the water transfer, DeVoe said the construction costs of the development is more expensive at the border site because the company typically develops land that already has arterial roads and utilities in place.

Removal of more than 2.4 million cubic yards of dirt on the site to cut down hills as much as 70 feet is a new cost to the company, DeVoe said.

The bond issue would be redeemed out of projected county income generated by the shopping center.

In asking for the bond, DeVoe presented figures showing the development would contribute nearly $1.8 million in annual sales tax and property tax income to the county.

Based on an estimate of four years to get the Hawkins development to full potential after breaking ground, DeVoe estimated the county would begin seeing an increase in general fund revenues of nearly $400,000 in year four of the bond.

The development would generate between half a million and $1 million in tax revenue annually until the bond is paid off, at which point the entire $1.8 million would go to the county.

Figures from county Assessor Joe Reynolds show the current property tax generated from the undeveloped site is $1,463 annually.

Citing a Port of Whitman-commissioned study by University of Idaho Economist Dr. Steve Peterson, Finch noted $80 million in retail sales annually leaves the Palouse in favor of shopping centers in Spokane and Lewiston.

“This is not a Whitman County project,” he said. “This is a good regional project.”

Finch said the project would “set the tenor” for development in the corridor.

“Without Hawkins, the corridor will be a series of steel buildings with a constant rotation of owners that would decay over the years,” he said.

Both Commissioners Finch and Partch stressed the importance of the development for retaining Whitman county youth. The large retail center, they added, will provide living-wage jobs in management, and will help retain and recruit top-flight employees for WSU and SEL.

“Whitman County is on the verge of an explosion of living wage jobs,” said Finch.

“I think this is our future financial security,” added Partch.

Partch said this project is the intended result of the county’s re-zoning of the Pullman-Moscow corridor to commercial a few years ago.

“Our choice was to do the easy thing and raise taxes, or to expand our tax base,” said Partch. “That’s economic development.”

Finch said the county’s bonding agent, Jack McLoughlin, is currently studying the viability of such a funding proposition.

“I can assure you that Whitman County’s going to do its due diligence on this,” said Finch.

Issuance of the bond will hinge on Hawkins obtaining water rights to the site, and a signed lease with Lowe’s Home Improvement store as an anchor tenant.

Getting those water rights is far from guaranteed. The Gazette reported last week that a state hearing board has been slated June 2-6 for the Hawkins project and a decision isn’t expected until at least six months after that.

Three of the transfers approved by the county Water Conservancy Board last July, and subsequently by the state Department of Ecology (DOE), were appealed by the city of Moscow.

The fourth transfer was denied by the DOE, and that decision has been appealed to the hearing board by Hawkins.

Moscow Public Works Director Les McDonald was at the Monday presentation on behalf of Mayor Nancy Chaney, and he assured the city’s appeals were based on a genuine concern for regional resources.

“The city’s interest really still is the water resources,” said McDonald. “I know there’s folks that doubt that.”

Whitman County Commissioners have speculated that Moscow’s appeal was based on an attempt to prevent commercial development on the west side of the border.

“You folks want to drill a huge well just across the state line,” a red-faced Finch replied to McDonald. “So there must be more water on the Idaho side of the line.”

When Moscow appealed the county planning department’s initial approval of the project, they cited a proposed well site north of the Palouse Empire Mall in Moscow would be negatively impacted by the development.

Impacts to the well site were also cited when the city appealed the county’s approval of James Toyota’s move from Moscow to the corridor.

Tuesday, January 8, 2008

"Hawkins puts price on growth; Company says infrastructure for proposed corridor development will cost $10.5 million"

From today's Moscow-Pullman Daily News:
Hawkins Companies on Monday asked Whitman County commissioners to sell bonds totalling $10.5 million to pay for public infrastructure for the company's proposed 700,000-square-foot shopping development on the Pullman-Moscow Highway.

Jeff DeVoe, spokesman for the Boise-based development company, also proposed the county and Hawkins enter into a public-private partnership in constructing public infrastructure for the site, just west of the Idaho state line. The partnership essentially would amount to Hawkins being responsible for the construction of public infrastructure and Whitman County agreeing to purchase it back at a predetermined price.

The public infrastructure would include a new water system, roads, sidewalks, and a sewer system. There also is preliminary talk of Hawkins constructing a fire station for the county at Hawkins' own cost.

DeVoe said the county would begin seeing sales and property tax revenues from the development of nearly $400,000 by the fourth year of a 30-year bond, according to conservative figures from the company's in-house estimator. Revenues would increase to more than $900,000 by year six, when the shopping center would be complete and full with tenants, and that revenue would remain steady until the bond was repaid. Tax income would be around $1.8 million per year once the bond was repaid. Any inflation would lead to revenue figures increasing.

Finch said the development would help Whitman County regain a portion of the roughly $80 million of retail sales it loses annually to neighboring markets. It also will provide living-wage jobs for area residents.

"It's going to be a big undertaking and it's going to change the landscape of Whitman County and Latah County," Finch said. "I strongly feel this will kick-start the whole economy of Whitman County. Once the ground is broken I really believe you are going to see a wave of people that want to get into the corridor.

"The corridor is going to be the growth engine for the county. Obviously I am excited about it."

Finch said the commissioners are going to consider all options before approving a bond.

"Much of the information (presented) I have seen, but we felt it is time to share it with the community," Finch said. "I want everyone to be sure Whitman County is going to do its due diligence."

Commissioners will hold at least two public meetings to discuss the idea of selling bonds, with the first coming Jan. 14. A decision is hoped to be reached Jan. 28, Finch said.

Commissioner Greg Partch said the commissioners want to hear from the public before making a decision.

"We are going to take the next few weeks to hear comments," Partch said. "We really want to make this as open as possible."

DeVoe said Hawkins hopes to begin construction as early as the beginning of summer.

"The county needs to get comfortable that they want to do this and if they do we need to get moving forward with this," DeVoe said. "It's our intention to get this shopping center built as soon as possible."

Finch said the project still hinges on Hawkins signing a lease with Lowe's as an anchor tenant for the shopping center and obtaining the water rights it is seeking, which are being held up in an appeals process.

In March, Hawkins applied for the rights to transfer 120 acre feet, or 40 million gallons, of water to its proposed development in addition to exchanging 100 acre feet of a 391-acre-feet water right to Colton for 23 acre feet of water.

The Whitman County Water Conservancy Board approved the transfers in July, but the Washington State Department of Ecology reversed its decision to approve the transfer that involved a surface-water diversion from the South Fork of the Palouse River. Ecology approved the other transfers.

Hawkins and the city of Moscow filed separate appeals with Washington's Pollution Control Hearings Board in November following the Department of Ecology's decision. Hawkins appealed the denial of the surface-water diversion from the South Fork of the Palouse River, while Moscow appealed the three approved transfers.

In its appeal, Moscow cited that each water right is located in two different bodies of public groundwater and the transfers would impair existing water rights, not be in the public's interest and would improperly modify the manner of the rights' intended use. The appeal also cited Ecology's failure to conduct an analysis of the average amount of water use from the rights over the past five years.

Hearings for the appeals are set to begin in March.

Moscow Public Works Director Les McDonald said Moscow is not opposed to growth, but it is concerned about conserving limited water resources.

"The city's interest really still is the water interest," McDonald said during the meeting. "Whitman County, Latah County and all the players share the same water resources.

"I don't think anyone in the city of Moscow begrudges Whitman County for trying to grow."

McDonald also said Moscow was open to seeking mediation in resolving the water-rights issues.

"The intent of that is to try to sit down and work through some of the issues," McDonald said.

DeVoe said he was unable to comment specifically on water rights because of the pending litigation.

Monday, January 7, 2008

BREAKING NEWS: Hawkins Companies asks county to seek $10.5 million bond for infrastructure

So apparently Hawkins Companies is not going to ask the county to supply water to its proposed development in the corridor (which would have been virtually impossible and very, very costly) and thus negating the need for its appeals for water rights transfers to be heard by the Pollution Control Hearing Board. Without knowing more details, I'm guessing the infrastructure it is asking for has more to do improving the mitigation measures for the Jones surface water rights transfer that Ecology deemed insufficient. I was told a while back by a highly-placed source that such increased mitigation would be spendy and could be a deal-breaker for Hawkins. Hawkins apparently has confidence that its' appeal will succeed with these new measures and that Moscow's appeals will fail and are willing to wait the year-plus it will take to resolve all these issues.

Whitman County must issue the bond. It's an investment in our future.

From the Moscow-Pullman Daily News website:
Hawkins Companies on Monday asked Whitman County Commissioners to take out a $10.5 million bond to pay for public infrastructure for a proposed shopping development on the Pullman-Moscow Highway. The project hinges on Hawkins obtaining water rights it is seeking and signing a lease with Lowe’s as an anchor tenant for the site. DeVoe said the county would begin seeing tax revenues from the development of nearly $400,000 by year four, and after the bond is repaid, tax income would be around $1.8 million per year. Commissioners will have two public meetings to discuss the idea of a bond, and hope to issue a decision by the end of the month.

Saturday, January 5, 2008

Hawkins to ask county for help; Company officials will meet with commissioners Monday seeking extension of infrastructure to proposed development

More from today's Moscow-Pullman Daily News:
Hawkins Companies officials on Monday are expected to ask Whitman County commissioners to extend public infrastructure to the site of its proposed 700,000-square-foot shopping development on the Pullman-Moscow Highway, just west of the Idaho state line.

Commissioners will meet with officials from the Boise-based company at 2:30 p.m. in the commissioners' chambers in the Whitman County Courthouse. The meeting is open to the public.

Commissioner Michael Largent said Hawkins representatives likely will ask for infrastructure investments in roads, sewer and water to make its development possible.

Largent said he is unsure of the cost associated with Hawkins' exact requests, but he suspects the price tag for the project will be considerable.

"One can reasonably be sure it will be in some millions - it's a fairly big deal," Largent said. "It's almost like another municipality in the county."

Whitman County would have several options for paying for the new infrastructure if approved, including bonding, using .09 sales-tax dollar allotment - money provided by the state and awarded by the county to assist rural communities with economic development - and by seeking grants.

Largent said the county most likely would have to pursue bonding to pay for at least a portion of the project. The bond would be paid back through property and sales taxes generated by the development.

"Whitman County isn't rolling in the money and it will probably need some type of bonding," Largent said.

One option that could potentially decrease the cost of the project would be working with Moscow to extend its services to the development, but that is a long shot unless Moscow changes its stance about the development.

"Right now it is my understanding Moscow has made it abundantly clear they don't like what Hawkins is doing," Largent said. "Whitman County and Moscow have a different perspective on economic growth, but we are no less concerned about our natural resources."

Largent is optimistic Whitman County and Moscow can work together in the future after three new members were elected to the Moscow City Council in November.

"At this point in time I am frankly looking forward to the opportunity for cooperation across the border," Largent said. "I think there are opportunities for cooperation."

City Council President Bill Lambert said he would be open to working with Whitman County and Hawkins if they get to the point where they are ready to move forward with the development.

"It's all about what-ifs," Lambert said. "If they get all this stuff done I think we need to take a look at what they propose to us. If they develop out there I think we should keep our eyes open and there's a possibility we could sell them some services.

"I don't think we should close the door."


Moscow Mayor Nancy Chaney said the city likely will send a representative to Monday's meeting and will be paying close attention to the situation.

"I think it is important that we are kept informed in this," she said.

Largent said Monday's meeting will be the first of many to come. A second meeting could be scheduled for as early as Jan. 14. The commissioners want to ensure they weigh public input on the issue and consider the risks and rewards of the project before moving forward.

"We can't afford to risk public money without a reasonable return to the public," Largent said. "We are not in the business of investing for a private company, but we are in the business of investing in the long-term interests of the county."

Commissioner Greg Partch said the Pullman-Moscow corridor could see a lot of new growth, but much of it will hinge on whether the Hawkins development gets off the ground. If it does, the corridor could be a great location for future growth within the county.

"Hawkins obviously is the big one," Partch said. "You have to provide for your own future, and development in the corridor is key to the future."

Largent agreed that the development would open the doors to more growth.

"Usually economic growth breeds economic growth," Largent said. "Just the jobs ... this one project would give Whitman County would be huge."

Both commissioners expressed their initial support for the development.

"One would think the commissioners would not interfere," Largent said. "But the twist here is the asking for public money. This is major money."

Hawkins must still clear several hurdles before any construction could begin.

"One can say they are proceeding with plans, but whether they proceed further depends on several things," Largent said. "They haven't pull the plug, and that's a good sign."

Atop Hawkins' list is securing water rights. In March, the company applied for the rights to transfer 120 acre feet, or 40 million gallons, of water to its proposed development in addition to exchanging 100 acre feet of a 391-acre-feet water right to Colton for 23 acre feet of water.

The Whitman County Water Conservancy Board approved the transfers in July, but the Washington State Department of Ecology reversed its decision to approve the transfer that involved a surface-water diversion from the South Fork of the Palouse River. Ecology approved the other transfers.

Hawkins and the city of Moscow filed separate appeals with Washington's Pollution Control Hearings Board in November following the Department of Ecology's decision. Hawkins appealed the denial of the surface-water diversion from the South Fork of the Palouse River, while Moscow appealed the three approved transfers.

In its appeal, Moscow cited that each water right is located in two different bodies of public groundwater and the transfers would impair existing water rights, not be in the public's interest and would improperly modify the manner of the rights' intended use. The appeal also cited Ecology's failure to conduct an analysis of the average amount of water use from the rights over the past five years.

Hearings for the appeals are set to begin in March.

Friday, January 4, 2008

BREAKING NEWS: Hawkins expected to ask Whitman County commissioners to extend infrastructure

From the Moscow-Pullman Daily News website:
Hawkins Companies officials on Monday are expected to ask Whitman County commissioners to extend public infrastructure to the site of its proposed 700,000-square-foot shopping development on the Pullman-Moscow Highway, just west of the Idaho state line.

Commissioners will meet with Hawkins officials at 2:30 p.m. in the commissioners’ chambers in the Whitman County Courthouse. The meeting is open to the public.

Commissioner Michael Largent said Hawkins representatives likely will ask for infrastructure investments in roads, sewer and water to make its development possible.

“A lot is at stake with this development and what happens there could potentially have a large, long-term impact on the Pullman-Moscow corridor and economic growth in our community well into the future,” Largent stated in an e-mail to the Daily News.
This is a move I absolutely expected. Hawkins is two years into this deal already. According to yesterday's Whitman County Gazette, this is how the water rights appeal process breaks down:
The Pollution Control Hearings Board (PCHB) has set June 2-6 hearing dates for appeals regarding water rights issued and denied at the Hawkins Development at the Idaho stateline on the Pullman-Moscow corridor. An additional day of June 26 has also been reserved if needed.

The Department of Ecology decided to grant three water rights transfers and deny one to Hawkins Companies LLC of Boise. Hawkins has issued an appeal to PCHB for the denial, and the City of Moscow has appealed the decisions to grant the three transfers. Also in the appeal is the transfer of water rights to the town of Colton.

PCHB decided to consolidate the four appeals into one hearing. Maia Bellon, assistant Attorney General representing the DOE in the matter, explained that by consolidating the cases, the board will be able to hear all the witnesses at the same time. As some of the same witnesses will be called by different entities in the matter, this will eliminate multiple testimonies by the witness.

Recent PCHB decisions have taken from two to 15 months to be issued.

“It depends on the nature of the hearing,” she said. With the complexities of the Hawkins appeals, it will most likely take longer. If the hearing truly does take the whole week, the decision could take five to 10 months.

“My gut would be at best six months,” Bellon said.
So that's at least another YEAR just to get a decision from the PCHB, and that assumes Hawkins' appeal is successful, Moscow's appeals fail and that no court action is pursued. Even if Hawkins wins the appeal, Ecology will still have to go through the process of granting the water rights transfers again.

There is no way Hawkins is going to wait that long. We're lucky they haven't pulled the plug yet due to Moscow's meddling. It's now the moment of truth for Whitman County. Either the county steps up and provides water and sewer to the Hawkins development or Hawkins walks and Whitman County never gets another developer interested in the corridor again. Period.

Will it be expensive? Definitely. Will the payoff be worth it? Beyond question. I estimate the Hawkins development will bring in $3.3 million a year in sales taxes alone for the county. Is it fair? No, but Hawkins has bent over backwards and they are only be forced to do this because moonbat idiots Nancy Chaney and Mark Solomon have been allowed to sabotage this project.

This is also a moment of truth for the city of Pullman, which has recently expressed an interest in sales tax sharing with the county in return for providing utility services in the corridor. Now is the time for the Pullman City Council to make that move.

And something has to be done to reform our local land use processes that allows these small groups of left-wing malcontents to kill beneficial projects through baseless legal delays.

Monday, December 17, 2007

Going (for the) Green

If you think all the global warming nitwittery has been limited to Stockholm and Bali lately, read on.

A December 6 Seattle Times story detailed some possible legislation concerning global warming in Washington, such as:
Seattle leaders have been talking to lawmakers about a bill that would impose an added fee for license tabs that would be scaled based on fuel efficiency. Gas-hogging SUVs would pay more; hybrids and electric cars would pay less.

While the actual fee amount would be up to the Legislature, Ceis said a reasonable average would be $100, with gas guzzlers possibly going as high as $300.
Of course, people with families like myself drive those "gas guzzler" SUVs and minivans. As the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers stated, "It's really nothing more than an added tax on families and small-business owners who need larger vehicles."

And if you thought the Department of Ecology had killed business in Washington border counties with their ridiculous stormwater requirements, wait until this is implemented:
Meanwhile, the state is already preparing to order cities and counties to study what effects new projects, such as office buildings, will have on the climate. State environmental law probably already requires it, though it hasn't been done in the past, said Jay Manning, head of the state Department of Ecology.

As for environmentalists, one of the top priorities for this year will be trying to change state land-use laws so communities have to factor in climate change as they plan for growth.

They, along with the Ecology Department, also would like to start an accounting system for larger companies or governments to track their greenhouse-gas emissions. That would help set the stage for future regulations aimed at cutting the gases.
God help us.

Wednesday, December 12, 2007

"Water dominates Pullman meeting of public officials; Council, legislators discuss effects on growth"

We have an excellent legislative team for Pullman. They all understand that environmental regulatory overkill causes the lack of affordable housing for working people and stifles economic development in Pullman. From today's Moscow-Pullman Daily News:
Water issues dominated much of the discussion in a town hall meeting between the Pullman City Council and Washington's 9th District legislators Tuesday.

Council members were joined by Sen. Mark Schoesler, Rep. Steve Hailey and new Rep. Joe Schmick to discuss state issues of concern to Pullman leaders. Other topics of conversation included funding for infrastructure, support for Washington State University projects and affordable housing.

Hailey said the solution to many of the concerns relates to water.

"It's a very high priority for me," he said. "If you run out of water, you've got nothing."

Hailey said water issues often slow the construction of new homes - especially those considered affordable housing. Water rights and environmental studies are expensive, and questions regarding recharge of the Palouse's two aquifers are seen as a roadblock by some developers.

He said research efforts must be increased to determine how to maintain water levels and support growth.

Legislators will convene for their 2008 session Jan. 14. Much of the agenda will revolve around the state's supplemental budget, but Hailey said he plans to push the need for more water research in the coming months.

"You have to have sufficient water to support more housing," he said. "I see that as a hurdle that has to be crossed in relatively short order ... In my mind, if we can solve the water issue, we can tackle the affordable housing issue."

Hailey also said a multimillion dollar water reclamation project - a joint effort between the city and WSU - could be funded in 2009-2011. The project would treat citywide wastewater for irritation.

"It's very doable," he said.

Schmick said he plans to defend the city's needs for funding in order to meet what he considers obscenely high requirements pertaining to stormwater management.

Earlier this year, the Washington State Department of Ecology issued statewide permits designed to manage the quality and quantity of runoff from development and to control stormwater discharges into sewer systems. Implementation of the requirements are expected to cost more than $4 million for Pullman. The city has received a grant for $75,000 and may be issued an additional $50,000 to jump-start the five-year permit program.

"There has to be a balance between environmental concerns and those of the cities and towns," Schmick said. "Our side of the aisle is very sympathetic to that."

Hailey agreed that the Department of Ecology has set unrealistically high standards for cities like Pullman.

"We'll try to get you some relief," he said. "I don't know what the answer is, but we'll keep pecking away at it."

Schmick, who was recently appointed to his position, said the meeting with Pullman leaders was helpful.

"We're here to represent the 9th District," he said. "We take this information back to Olympia."

QUICKREAD

WHAT HAPPENED: The Pullman City Council met with Washington's 9th District legislators Sen. Mark Schoesler, Rep. Steve Hailey and Rep. Joe Schmick for a meeting Tuesday. Water issues dominated much of the conversation which also inlcuded affordable housing and Washington State Department of Ecology requirements.

WHAT IT MEANS: Legislators and the council agree that water is a major issue of concern in Pullman and Whitman County.

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT: Legislators will convene for their 2008 session Jan. 14 in Olympia. Schoesler, Hailey and Schmick said they will pass along their constituents' concerns to other state leaders.

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

Queen Calls Special Session to Save Her Throne

Last year, a King County Superior Court judge struck down I-747 as being unconstitutional. I-747 was the ballot measure passed on 2001 that limited property tax increases to 1% a year without voter approval. One of the plaintiffs in that lawsuit was Whitman County.

Legal technicalities notwithstanding, it is clear what the intent of 58% of Washington voters was when they passed I-747. The Democratic supermajority in Olympia was urged last session to take action and restore the 1% property cap via legislation. The Rats punted, saying the Washington Supreme Court would reverse the decision. The Supreme Court, by a 5-4 margin, upheld the lower court decision last month. Oops. Bad timing for Queen Christine and the Dems, what with Dino Rossi throwing his hat into the 2008 gubernatorial race and recent polls showing the election a virtual dead heat. The recent passage of I-960 by voters shows, that despite numerous obituaries being written by the left, the taxpayer revolt in Washington is alive and well. Allowing a big tax increase to go forward is political hemlock for the Rats. And they only have themselves to blame. Earlier this year, they passed the largest spending increase in Washington history.

Now Queen Christine has called a special session of the legislature to restore the 1% property tax cap. As usual, she is demonstrating the cowardly, waffling, blow with the wind, lead from behind approach to governing she showed with the Alaskan Way Viaduct. As the Seattle Times story reported:
"I'm glad she has called the special session because we need to protect the will of the voters," Rossi said in a statement. "But I have a feeling she only took this step out of political expediency, not concern for the taxpayers."
But who cares as long as the 1% property tax cap gets restored.

Predictably, the "progressive" moonbats are howling, for example, here, here, and here.

And from the "strange political bedfellows" department, so are the Whitman County Commissioners. According to the Moscow-Pullman Daily News website:
Whitman County Commissioner Greg Partch said the 1 percent cap makes it difficult for smaller taxing districts to operate and the move to reinstate the initiative is based on politics alone. For Whitman County, 1 percent only amounts to $37,000 a year in tax revenue.
Pullman Mayor Glenn Johnson and City Supervisor John Sherman have applauded the overturn of I-747 and the Daily News editors opined last week that:
Bottom line, the control of property taxes was returned to the local governments where it belongs - but not before some budgetary belt-tightening.

Capping tax increases made it difficult to provide some services.

If Pullman or Colfax needs a 3-percent increase in property taxes to provide the services local residents demand, then those city councils should have the power to do so.

Local voters are an excellent barometer - through the ballot box - of how well those elected officials budget tax dollars. That power should not be in the hands of west side voters who think they can dictate - through the initiative process - how much tax is too much for people in Whitman County.

No one likes to raise taxes and responsible local government is no exception. But the need to increase taxes is necessary from time to time and is best done at the local level by those who know just how precious each penny is.
I sympathize with our local governments. But the reforms in Olympia need to be regulatory, not to the tax code. What would help Pullman and Whitman County more are drastic changes to the State Environmental Policy Act and the Department of Ecology. Wal-Mart would be in Pullman now, contributing over a million dollars a year to the tax base if not for the long, drawn out SEPA appeal process. The Pullman City Council must take some of the blame for this by mandating that SEPA appeals go through the superior court, which is why we have this latest delay of over a year in the appellate court. In most Washington towns, SEPA appeals are heard by the city council. In Whitman County, the Hawkins Companies development in the Pullman-Moscow corridor would be contributing $3 million plus to the tax coffers if not for the meddling by the Deprtment of Ecology. And let's not even get started on Ecology's business-killing stormwater requirements.

All this environmentalist nitwittery from Olympia cannot, and should not, be balanced on the backs of home owners. Housing in Whitman County is already among the least affordable in the state. Can you imagine how much more unaffordable housing would be with annual 4% property tax increases?

And its not just Whitman County. A recent WSU Center for Real Estate Research study concluded that the Growth Management Act has increased the cost of homes in Washington. The voters of this state spoke in 2001. Enough is enough. If cities and counties have a hard time making ends meet, then its time to clear away the dead wood of bureaucratic regulations, not reach deeper into taxpayer's wallets.

Friday, November 9, 2007

"Hawkins appeals denied water right transfer; Developer files notice with Department of Ecology on fourth transfer"

This is great news. Despite all the wrongheaded efforts by the Queen of the Meanies, King Solomon, and our own Department of Ecological Fallacies, Hawkins has not given up on Whitman County. From today's Moscow-Pullman Daily News:

Hawkins Companies isn't ready to end its battle over water rights needed for its proposed 700,000-square-foot shopping development on the Pullman-Moscow Highway.

Hawkins filed an appeal with Washington's Pollution Control Hearings Board this week over the Department of Ecology's decision to deny a transfer from the South Fork of the Palouse River.

Representatives from the Boise-based Hawkins Companies were unable to be reached for comment.

In October, Ecology denied one of four water-right transfers the company was seeking to be used for the development just across the state line from Idaho. The Whitman County Water Conservancy Board had recommended the approval of all four transfers. Ecology reversed the water conservancy board's decision to approve a surface-water diversion from the South Fork of the Palouse River because the required plan to "mitigate," or make up for, effects to Paradise Creek was inadequate.

Keith Stoffel, a section manager at Ecology, wrote in a ruling letter to Hawkins that the diversion was denied because of issues with wastewater and the conservancy board's decision to allow year-round use in "unavoidable circumstances," which "would negatively impact Paradise Creek."

Hawkins planned only to use the South Fork of the Palouse River water right from January to May and from September to December, unless circumstances required the use of the water right from June to August.

Earlier this week, the city of Moscow filed an appeal over the three approved transfers, citing that each water right was located in two different bodies of public groundwater and the transfers would impair existing water rights, not be in the public's interest and would improperly modify the manner of the rights' intended use. The appeal also cited Ecology's failure to conduct an analysis of the average amount of water use from the rights over the past five years.

In March, the company applied to transfer 120 acre-feet, or 40 million gallons, of water to its proposed development in addition to applying to transfer 100 acre-feet of a 391-acre-feet water right to Colton in exchange for 23 acre-feet of water. The water conservancy board approved the transfers in July.

Hawkins officials previously said the company hoped to begin construction this fall.

Monday, November 5, 2007

BREAKING NEWS: Moscow appeals Hawkins water right

Well, now we know the identity of one of the three parties filing appeals against the Hawkins water rights transfers that I reported on last month: the City of Moscow (my guess is King Solomon's Palouse Water Conservation Network is in there, as well as the Sierra Club.) The real question is whether these groups have any legal standing to appeal.

And just before the Moscow City Council election tomorrow. Perfect timing. I guess Linda Pall was wrong. Moscow must have the resources to continue the war against Whitman County indefinitely. Why not? They get all our sales tax money. Now they turn it against us. I just can't wait until the next big retail development is announced in Moscow. Payback is a bitch. From the Moscow-Pullman Daily News website:
The city Moscow has appealed the decision to grant water right transfers to Boise-based Hawkins Companies for the proposed development of a 700,000-square foot shopping center off of the Pullman-Moscow Highway.

The city filed the appeal with Washington’s Pollution Control Hearings Board.

The appeal stems from a Department of Ecology decision in October that affirmed the Whitman County Water Conservancy Board’s recommendation to approve three water rights transfers to be used for the development just across the state line from Idaho.

Moscow cited in its appeal that each water right was located in two different bodies of public groundwater and the transfer would impair existing water rights, not be in the public’s interest and would improperly modify the manner of the rights’ intended use. The appeals also cited Ecology’s failure to conduct an analysis of the average amount of water use from the rights over the past five years.

Friday, November 2, 2007

"A check, a smile, and a big price tag"

This was a fabulous editorial from Steve McClure in last Monday's Moscow-Pullman Daily News smacking down the Department of Ecology:
Remember that poor guy from the Washington State Department of Ecology who had to tell the Pullman City Council earlier this year the city was getting smacked with serious stormwater regulations?

We do.

He stood his ground at City Hall with nothing but the party line but offered up a $75,000 grant like it was Willy Wonka’s Golden Ticket.

That 75 grand seemed like it was better than nothing as the city came to grips with regulations to manage the quantity and quality of stormwater runoff within Pullman.

Now that the initial price tag has been attached to the process, however, that $75,000 seems like it’s pretty doggone close to nothing.

It’s going to cost the city $4.4 million over the next five years to pay for all the requirements in the permit process.

The state loves to bang the drum of indignation when the federal government passes down edicts without attaching any money to pay for new programs and rules. For some reason, though, the state doesn’t seem to have a problem doing the same thing to local governments.

In Pullman, that could lead to the creation of a utility district, which will collect a tariff from property owners in a way similar to water and sewer services. The city also can tack on a fee for developers and have them pay to bring new construction areas up to permit standards.

Apparently, the folks at Ecology don’t think it’s a problem to have local taxpayers make up the $4,325,000 difference.

We don’t usually cover check passings. We might make an exception if someone from Olympia wants to swing through Pullman to present an oversized voucher for that $75,000. That would be something to see — particularly if Gov. Chris Gregoire or another notable politician were to make the journey.

We’d like to see if they could actually pull off the exchange with a smile on their face.

Of course, they can afford to smile. They’re not the ones who have to foot the bill.